Hundreds of additional titles available for
online reading when you join Gateway to the Classics
 IT much increased Curdie's feeling of the strangeness of the whole affair, that, the next morning, when they
were at work in the mine, the party of which he and his father were two, just as if they had known what had
happened to him the night before, began talking about all manner of wonderful tales that were abroad in the
country, chiefly, of course, those connected with the mines, and the mountains in which they lay. Their wives
and mothers and grandmothers were their chief authorities. For when they sat by their firesides they heard
their wives telling their children the selfsame tales, with little differences, and here and there one they
had not heard before, which they had
 heard their mothers and grandmothers tell in one or other of the same cottages.
At length they came to speak of a certain strange being they called Old Mother Wotherwop. Some said their
wives had seen her. It appeared as they talked that not one had seen her more than once. Some of their mothers
and grandmothers, however, had seen her also, and they all had told them tales about her when they were
children. They said she could take any shape she liked, but that in reality she was a withered old woman, so
old and so withered that she was as thin as a sieve with a lamp behind it; that she was never seen except at
night, and when something terrible had taken place, or was going to take place—such as the falling in of
the roof of a mine, or the breaking out of water in it.
She had more than once been seen—it was always at night—beside some well, sitting on the brink of
it, and leaning over and stirring it with her forefinger, which was six times as long as any of the rest. And
whoever for months after drank of that well was sure to be ill. To this, one of them, however, added that he
remembered his mother saying that whoever in bad health drank of the well was sure to get
 better. But the majority agreed that the former was the right version of the story- for was she not a witch,
an old hating witch, whose delight was to do mischief? One said he had heard that she took the shape of a
young woman sometimes, as beautiful as an angel, and then was most dangerous of all, for she struck every man
who looked upon her stone-blind.
Peter ventured the question whether she might not as likely be an angel that took the form of an old woman, as
an old woman that took the form of an angel. But nobody except Curdie, who was holding his peace with all his
might, saw any sense in the question. They said an old woman might be very glad to make herself look like a
young one, but who ever heard of a young and beautiful one making herself look old and ugly?
Peter asked why they were so much more ready to believe the bad that was said of her than the good. They
answered, because she was bad. He asked why they believed her to be bad, and they answered, because she did
bad things. When he asked how they knew that, they said, because she was a bad creature. Even if they didn't
know it, they said, a woman like that was so
 much more likely to be bad than good. Why did she go about at night? Why did she appear only now and then, and
on such occasions? One went on to tell how one night when his grandfather had been having a jolly time of it
with his friends in the market town, she had served him so upon his way home that the poor man never drank a
drop of anything stronger than water after it to the day of his death. She dragged him into a bog, and tumbled
him up and down in it till he was nearly dead.
"I suppose that was her way of teaching him what a good thing water was," said Peter; but the man, who liked
strong drink, did not see the joke.
"They do say," said another, "that she has lived in the old house over there ever since the little princess
left it. They say too that the housekeeper knows all about it, and is hand and glove with the old witch. I
don't doubt they have many a nice airing together on broomsticks. But I don't doubt either it's all nonsense,
and there's no such person at all."
"When our cow died," said another, 'she was seen going round and round the cowhouse the
 same night. To be sure she left a fine calf behind her—I mean the cow did, not the witch. I wonder she
didn't kill that, too, for she'll be a far finer cow than ever her mother was."
"My old woman came upon her one night, not long before the water broke out in the mine, sitting on a stone on
the hillside with a whole congregation of cobs about her. When they saw my wife they all scampered off as fast
as they could run, and where the witch was sitting there was nothing to be seen but a withered bracken bush. I
made no doubt myself she was putting them up to it."
And so they went on with one foolish tale after another, while Peter put in a word now and then, and Curdie
diligently held his peace. But his silence at last drew attention upon it, and one of them said:
"Come, young Curdie, what are you thinking of?"
"How do you know I"m thinking of anything?" asked Curdie.
"Because you're not saying anything."
"Does it follow then that, as you are saying so much, you're not thinking at all?" said Curdie.
 "I know what he's thinking," said one who had not yet spoken; "he's thinking what a set of fools you are to
talk such rubbish; as if ever there was or could be such an old woman as you say! I"m sure Curdie knows better
than all that comes to."
"I think," said Curdie, "it would be better that he who says anything about her should be quite sure it is
true, lest she should hear him, and not like to be slandered."
"But would she like it any better if it were true?" said the same man. "If she is What they say—I don't
know—but I never knew a man that wouldn't go in a rage to be called the very thing he was."
"If bad things were true of her, and I knew it," said Curdie, "I would not hesitate to say them, for I will
never give in to being afraid of anything that's bad. I suspect that the things they tell, however, if we knew
all about them, would turn out to have nothing but good in them; and I won't say a word more for fear I should
say something that mightn't be to her mind."
They all burst into a loud laugh.
 "Hear the parson!" they cried. "He believes in the witch! Ha! ha!"
"He's afraid of her!"
"And says all she does is good!"
"He wants to make friends with her, that she may help him to find the silver ore."
"Give me my own eyes and a good divining rod before all the witches in the world! And so I'd advise you too,
Master Curdie; that is, when your eyes have grown to be worth anything, and you have learned to cut the hazel
fork." Thus they all mocked and jeered at him, but he did his best to keep his temper and go quietly on with
his work. He got as close to his father as he could, however, for that helped him to bear it. As soon as they
were tired of laughing and mocking, Curdie was friendly with them, and long before their midday meal all
between them was as it had been.
But when the evening came, Peter and Curdie felt that they would rather walk home together without other
company, and therefore lingered behind when the rest of the men left the mine.